The three mustaches tackle a frustrating case out of Pennsylvania that will leave you wondering whether forgiveness is divine, or criminal negligence. When Aimee Willard disappeared in June of 1996, the police had no shortage of suspects to investigate -- some of whom came from their very own ranks. But, the target of their search was eventually revealed to be a ghost from their past that kept coming back to haunt them. If you miss this episode, we forgive you. Just promise not to let it happen again...

Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices